Now is best time to visit St. Barts’ top hotels

The très French island of St. Barts is acting  more like  itself than ever before.

After COVID put a damper on billionaire revelry last year, this season it was easy to forget that a pandemic was happening. Masks just aren’t en vogue — thanks to rigorous and ever-shifting testing requirements prior to arrival.  

Charter flights — the sole non-nautical means of transport to and fro the isle — arrived every seven minutes during the holidays.

Luxury flight operator Tradewind, which flies to St. Barts via San Juan and St. Maarten, sold out and added additional December flights, which then also sold out. Even now, it’s wise to book far ahead.

VIPs filled Gustavia’s harbor with hundreds of mega-yachts and rental home inventory evaporated almost a year ahead of New Year’s, as those jilted by COVID in 2020 cashed in unused resort and villa credit, villa brokerage Sibarth told The Post.

The seasoned coterie of St. Barts bottle poppers returned to Nikki Beach for raucous lunches, Nebuchadnezzars of rosé and dancing on the beach and at exclusive restaurants like Fouquet’s, the Sand Bar, and the new South of France-themed RIVYERA at Le Christopher by chef Arnaud Faye.

A plane landing on St. Barts.
Watching small planes land and takeoff on St. Barts’ itty-bitty runway is quite the spectator sport.

So where does that leave meager mortals who want a taste of French Caribbean magnificence? Hotels. And damn good ones.

Hôtel Le Toiny and Hôtel Barrière Le Carl Gustaf, two island hot spots with very different flavors, are refreshed and operating with peak precision. 

Opened back in 1992, with 14 villa-style standalone rooms, Le Toiny has never stopped growing. Today, the Relais & Chateaux hotel, helmed by hotelier Charlie Nicoll, has 22 spiffy suites that sprawl like Hamptons pool houses. 

The outdoor restaurant at Le Toiny.
Enjoy romantic barefoot dining on the beach at Hotel Le Toiny.
Hotel Le Toiny

Exterior shot of a private pool at Le Toiny.
Le Toiny’s suites sport private pools.
Hotel Le Toiny

An aerial shot of Le Toiny.
Toiny Bay is the resort’s namesake, which it overlooks.
Hotel Le Toiny

In December, Le Toiny upped their gambit with a brand-new and even larger, “villa over the ocean” — a new 7,000-square-foot, four-bedroom villa with a 900-square-foot pool and tropical garden. February rates start at $2,248 per night.

It has also unveiled Villa Nureyev, the hotel’s only oceanside villa.

Named after the Russian ballet dancer Rudolf Nureyev — who purchased the home in the 1980s — it also features four bedrooms and a 3,000-square-foot terrace, with a kitchen area, a floating deck and guest cottage. February rates are $1,473 per night.

But Le Toiny — with its infinite perks — is rural. Those who prefer snooping on yacht owners or spying on Leonardo DiCaprio will prefer Hôtel Barrière Le Carl Gustaf in the heart of Gustavia.

A deck at Hôtel Barrière Le Carl Gustaf.
Spot celebrities from your private deck at Hôtel Barrière Le Carl Gustaf on St. Barts.
Le Carl Gustaf

Back in 2013, the hotel closed and was bought by Groupe Barrière in 2015. After a  multi-year renovation by French designers Gilles & Boissier (known for the Baccarat in New York) the resort reopened its doors to acclaim this season. 

Today, its detached suites still roll down the hillside toward the harbor and the island’s ritzy Shell Beach.  But they boast top design and playful amenities — like private plunge pools, tennis racket bug swatters and water exercise bikes — not to mention the best views money can buy. Rates start at $1,473 per night in February.